Jury Findings

Final findings and judgement from the Independent People's Tribunal on the World Bank in India

The 12-member jury panel delivers findings at the Independent People's Tribunal
The jury panel delivers their findings at the conclusion of the Tribunal September 2007
Jury members listen intently to testimony
Jury members listen to testimony from affected communities

The Verdict

"Our conclusion based on these testimonies is that the majority of World Bank sponsored projects do not serve their stated purpose, nor do they benefit the poor of India. Instead in many cases, they have caused grievous and irreversible damage to those they intend to serve."

The evidence we have heard adds up to a disturbing picture of the World Bank's underlying agenda and operations, as it benefits those privileged with capital but pushes to despair the already vulnerable.

We recommend that the World Bank should compensate those it has harmed gravely through its policies, projects, and neglect in carrying out its own environmental and social safeguards.

The Full Statement

Unless there are instituted clear and transparent mechanisms through which World Bank activities and policies can be independently monitored and audited, it would be better for the World Bank to quit operations in India.

The jury called for comprehensive reforms to the World Bank's operational policies, greater transparency in its dealings with the Indian government, and meaningful compensation for communities harmed by Bank-funded projects.

Download the Findings

The full jury panel assembled at the Tribunal
The distinguished 12-member jury panel who heard testimony and rendered the final judgement

The Jury

The jury sat before the tribunal, heard depositions and passed the final judgement. These distinguished experts in their fields were selected by the groups involved in organizing the tribunal.

Amit Bhaduri Economist, Professor Emeritus at JNU Aruna Roy Social Activist, Right to Information Arundhati Roy Author, Booker Prize Winner Alejandro Nadal Professor of Economics, El Colegio de Mexico Bruce Rich Environmental Defense, Author
Chief Justice K.K. Usha Former Chief Justice, Kerala High Court
Justice P.B. Sawant Former Supreme Court Justice
Justice Suresh Former Mumbai High Court Justice
Meher Engineer Physicist, Former Director Bose Institute
Ramaswamy Iyer Former Secretary of Water Resources
Romilla Thapar Emeritus Professor of History, JNU
S.P. Shukla Former Secretary of Finance Sulak Sivaraksa Right Livelihood Award Recipient

View complete jury biographies →

Testimony being presented at the Tribunal
Country Director of World Bank, Isabel Guerrero

The World Bank's Response

The World Bank declined to participate in the Tribunal proceedings but issued statements in response to the charges. The Tribunal subsequently responded to the Bank's statements.